Mark,
One piece is a lot easier to make. A little different to use. Better ask your wife what she likes.
I have one last piece of that tiger maple, it's yours if you can use it. May be a little short for a one piece. Have some more plain maple that will work fine just not as pretty.
Pick a day and I'll have a class for you, two days if you want. I really need to get that walnut moved if there's any chance you could help.