Hand Tools: Where/How to Learn?

[drw]

Froglips' recent thread on "Why Do You Like Hand Tools" was extremely interesting and thought provoking. While I have been interested in woodworking for many years, it has only been in the past few years that I have invested any time,energy and dollars into it. Until this thread was posted, my inclination has been to acquire power tools and develop my skills in using them. While I am still "mostly" of that mindset, I can now see a great deal of value/benefit in developing a blended set of skills. At this point in my woodworking journey I still have much to learn, but I thoroughly enjoy the process and I take a great deal of pride and pleasure in each successful step. My leaning process for new power tools has simply been to read the directions, set it up, turn it on and learn as I go. Does this same process work for hand tool techniques? Intuitively, I am sure it does for many of you...but for some reason I think such self-taught techniques would be similar to my self-taught golf swing...it isn't pretty and it certainly isn't very effective, but...nonetheless, I really enjoy the game.

Cheers,
ccasion1
Donn

 

[CarvedTones]

Well, I can certainly recommend the Woodwright's school in Pittsboro and you want to start watching the show (Woodwrioght's Shop) on UNC-TV.

 

[CarvedTones]

Oh yeah - I forgot about this link:
http://www.youtube.com/user/robc45

Rob Cosman's YouTube page.

 

[froglips]

Glad that thread was so helpful

I would have to say that hand tools aren't quite the same (instruction booklet wise). They are part of a process. So I'd suggest learning the process and finding tools to fit it. Sadly, thats not how most tool dealers operate

Sharpening is one of the most important skills, as most handtools are edge tools. I'd start there. Pick a system and start with a 3/4 bench chisel, block plane and a #5 jack plane.

There are lots of great books, videos and schools out there.

I fear hand tool work is still more in the realm of speculation and mystery. Lots of folks have "new ideas" or "special must have gizmo's". Sadly, for a host of reasons, the methods of work are mostly lost to history.

I mention that, in hopes of saving you some of the overwhelming irritation I find looking for information.

The book I wish I had started with isn't really a book. It the writings of Adam Cherubini in Popular Woodworking. All his articles are now on a DVD.

For Classes, check out Bill Anderson at http://www.edwardsmountainwoodworks.com who is also an instructor at the Woodwright's School.

He also teaches at the John C. Campbell Folks School http://www.folkschool.org/

There is another school that is highly regarded: http://www.countryworkshops.org/

I've taken a class at Kelly Mehler's School, and can't say enough good things about it: http://www.kellymehler.com/

For video's to own or rent, I'm a strong proponent of the Jim Kingshott set of 4. I'd also add Chris Schwarz "Corse Medium and Fine" dvd.

Lastly, a good workbench at the right height is critical to hand tool success. Again, Chris Schwarz has done a lot in that department. His book is outstanding.

Its a fun ride, and we are all here to help in anyway we can

Jim

 

[drw]

Andy, Jim...great recommendations, thank you! I am confident your suggestions on informational resources will prove to be very, very helpful. Also, once I do retire (June 30th:icon_thum), I do plan to enroll in some workshops.

Again, thank you!
Donn

 

[CarvedTones]

Sharpening is one of the most important skills, as most handtools are edge tools.

Jim,

You need to be a more discerning shopper; I buy my tools sharp. :rotflm::rotflm::rotflm:

Donn,

I wanted to add to Jim's comments about the workbench, but expand a little on what "good" means besides height. Take a look at this picture:

That workbench is obviously not at the optimum height. :rolf: But it is the only thing I have that is solid enough to stay completely still when using a plane. A lot of workbenches that appear to be really solid during other operations move too much to use a hand plane on. Hand saws are rough on the structural integrity of work benches also, though you can still saw on one that moves a little; just be sure to clear the surface before you start sawing or you will shake everything off (DAMHIKT).

 

[nelsone]

Consider joining MWTCA if you are interested in hand tools.

 

[Gofor]

Here is an interesting on-line read about the way they used to do it at the turn of the century. Don't let the title about it being a "Boy's Guide to carpentry" fool you. There is a lot of good info on tool selection, use, sharpening, etc. I dare say if you master the techniques in the book, you will be an excellent hand tool user.

http://doit101.com/boycarpentry/contents.htm

Go