I just looked at the ten most recommended oil filled comps and they are all much louder, much bigger, much heavier, more expensive.Mike,
After all those years at IR I will never own a oil free unit. There is no guess as to how long it will last and they never have large capacity tanks cause then they would be pusher even harder. Look around, there are smaller units out there with oil cooled pumps.
I have a RolAire that is too big, too loud, and too heavy to move around a lot. I plan to keep it in the shop. I want one that can drive pin nails, run a small (very small) paint sprayer, blow saw dust off the drill press and band saw, blow up lawnmower tires, etc. and be very easy to carry upstairs or out to the car when needed. It will probably have a 6-8 foot hose. It will be used one or two times a month at most. For bigger jobs I will haul out the slightly larger RolAire.
That is why I am thinking of the smallest California Air compressor.
Tell me why I'm wrong.